Linhares Law
About
Visas▾
U.S. Visa Categories
  • EB-2 NIW→
  • EB-1→
  • E-2→
  • L-1→
  • O-1→
  • H-1B→
  • EB-5→
  • EB-3→
  • I-130→
  • VAWA→
View all visa categories →
TeamRecognitionPressTestimonialsInsights
Schedule a Consultation
AboutVisasTeamRecognitionPressTestimonialsInsights
U.S. Visa Categories
  • EB-2 NIW
  • EB-1
  • E-2
  • L-1
  • O-1
  • H-1B
  • EB-5
  • EB-3
  • I-130
  • VAWA
Schedule a Consultation
Linhares Law

The Time Is Now.

Linhares Law is a boutique U.S. immigration law firm serving international professionals, executives, investors and families.

Institutional practice · Orlando · Miami · New York · Salt Lake City

Navigation

  • About
  • Visas
  • Team
  • Recognition
  • Press
  • Testimonials
  • Insights
  • Contact

Offices

  • OrlandoFlorida
  • MiamiFlorida
  • New YorkNew York
  • Salt Lake CityUtah

Contact

  • info@linhareslaw.com
  • +1 (407) 725-4988
  • WhatsApp: +1 (407) 725-4988
© 2026 Linhares Law · All rights reserved.U.S. Immigration · Boutique Law Firm
  1. Home/
  2. Insights/
  3. Proposed professional endeavor in EB-2 NIW: why a résumé is not enough
EB-2 NIW

Proposed professional endeavor in EB-2 NIW: why a résumé is not enough

André LinharesOct 06, 20267 min read
Proposed professional endeavor in EB-2 NIW: why a résumé is not enough

Latest insights

  • Family Petition and Lawful Permanent Residence in the United States: Why Are They Different Concepts?

    Family Petition and Lawful Permanent Residence in the United States: Why Are They Different Concepts?

    Nov 17, 2026
  • Conditional Permanent Residence in the United States: What Does It Mean in a Family Context?

    Conditional Permanent Residence in the United States: What Does It Mean in a Family Context?

    Nov 16, 2026
  • Children and Family-Based Immigration to the United States: Why Must Each Relationship Be Understood in Context?

    Children and Family-Based Immigration to the United States: Why Must Each Relationship Be Understood in Context?

    Nov 15, 2026
  • Marriage and U.S. Immigration: What Does the Relationship Mean?

    Marriage and U.S. Immigration: What Does the Relationship Mean?

    Nov 14, 2026
In this article
  1. Profession, résumé, and proposed endeavor answer different questions
  2. What USCIS expects from the description
  3. Starting a business is not mandatory
  4. The Dhanasar case itself shows why the scope matters
  5. Where the résumé actually fits
  6. A useful description must be consistent with the evidence
  7. What should not take the place of the proposed endeavor
  8. The definition begins the analysis; it is not advance approval

EB-2 NIW

Para compreender como sua trajetória se relaciona com uma atuação profissional específica e com os critérios do NIW, conheça a atuação da Linhares Law em EB-2 NIW.

Conheça a área de EB-2 NIW →

In EB-2 NIW, the proposed professional endeavor or project describes what a person intends to do in the United States, how they intend to advance that work, and the impact they project. A résumé can help demonstrate capacity, but it does not replace that definition—and the concept does not require starting a business.

In EB-2 NIW, the proposed professional endeavor or project is the specific work a person intends to carry out in the United States. It is not merely the name of the profession, the desired position, a list of duties, or a résumé summary. The description needs to show what will be done, by what means, with what objectives, and what prospective impact is asserted.

The English term used by USCIS and by Matter of Dhanasar is proposed endeavor. It is sometimes rendered in Portuguese as “empreendimento proposto,” but that expression does not mean every person must start a business. For that reason, “proposed professional endeavor or project” can make the concept clearer.

This definition is decisive because the three NIW prongs connect to it. The first examines the endeavor’s substantial merit and national importance. The second asks whether the person is well positioned to advance it. The third evaluates whether, on balance, it would benefit the United States to waive the job offer and labor certification. The Linhares Law guide to the EB-2 NIW structure explores those two layers of analysis.

Profession, résumé, and proposed endeavor answer different questions

A profession identifies the general field of work. “Engineer,” “physician,” “researcher,” “executive,” or “technology specialist” still says little about what a person will specifically do in the United States.

A résumé organizes the past. It can document education, experience, skills, projects, publications, results, and recognition. Those elements may be relevant, especially to show that the person can carry out what they propose.

The proposed endeavor looks to future activity. It should enable the reader to understand:

  • what problem, need, or opportunity will be addressed

  • what specific work the person intends to perform

  • which projects, methods, services, products, or activities are part of that endeavor

  • why that endeavor has the asserted impact

  • how the person intends to develop it in the United States

The three dimensions must relate to one another, but they are not interchangeable. A strong résumé does not define the project by itself. A detailed proposal, in turn, does not automatically prove that the person can carry it out.

What USCIS expects from the description

USCIS Policy Alert PA-2025-03 states that an endeavor is more specific than a general occupation. Its guidance uses an engineer as an example: rather than simply listing typical engineering duties, the explanation should identify the area, projects, and objectives that make up the proposed work.

This does not impose a single model of writing. The description is useful because it makes the petition’s assertions verifiable. If a proposal mentions an impact in a sector, for example, it must be possible to identify what activity would generate that impact and by what path. If it projects economic, social, scientific, cultural, or educational benefits, the relationship between the work and those effects needs to be explained.

A broad statement such as “use my experience to contribute to the U.S. economy” does not make that relationship clear. It announces a conclusion but does not identify the work to be analyzed.

Starting a business is not mandatory

A proposed endeavor and a business are different concepts. A person may intend to advance their work:

  • as an employee of one or more organizations

  • in research or development within a university, laboratory, or company

  • through professional practice subject to applicable licenses

  • in collaboration with institutions, clients, or partners

  • as a self-employed professional, founder, or entrepreneur

  • through a coherent combination of these forms

Employment or a business can be the means through which a project is developed. It is not, by itself, the project’s complete definition. Saying only “work as a manager at an American company” or “open a consulting firm” still leaves open which activities will be performed, which objectives will be pursued, and what impact is intended to be shown.

The NIW permits a request to waive the job offer and labor certification when the legal standard is met. That possibility does not make starting a business a requirement, nor does it mean every self-employed person or entrepreneur qualifies.

The Dhanasar case itself shows why the scope matters

In the official precedent *Matter of Dhanasar*, the petitioner was an engineer. The record, however, was not analyzed only under that professional label. The decision examined specific research and development activities in air and space propulsion systems and, separately, aerospace-engineering teaching activities.

The research showed substantial merit and national importance in that record. The decision connected the work to scientific advances, national security, and competitiveness in the space sector. The teaching activities, although meritorious, were not accompanied by sufficient evidence of broader impact in STEM education.

The contrast does not mean research always meets the standard or teaching can never meet it. It shows that two activities carried out by the same person may receive different analyses according to the description and the evidence of prospective impact.

Where the résumé actually fits

Once the endeavor is identified, the person’s background helps answer a different question: why is this person well positioned to advance it?

Education, skills, knowledge, a record of related work, plans, progress, and interest from third parties are among the factors cited by Dhanasar and by USCIS PA-2025-03, which incorporated that guidance into the Policy Manual in 2025. Relevance comes not only from an item’s prestige, but from its connection to future work.

A degree may demonstrate technical training. A prior project may show experience carrying out similar work. A publication may document knowledge or contribution. A contract, funding, or expression of interest may support that third parties see value in the initiative. None of these examples works automatically in every case.

That connection also avoids two opposite errors: submitting many exhibits without explaining what each proves, and describing an ambitious proposal without evidence that the person has resources, experience, support, or progress consistent with carrying it out.

A useful description must be consistent with the evidence

Defining the proposed endeavor is not an exercise in creating the broadest possible narrative. The farther the description is from the actual work, the harder it becomes to support it with relevant and consistent documents.

A coherent formulation usually allows evidence to be organized around concrete questions:

  1. What is the specific activity, and what value does it offer?

  2. What prospective impact can it achieve, and why does that impact have broader implications?

  3. What shows that the person can advance the activity?

  4. Why do the evidence, viewed together, support the requested waiver?

These questions help structure the analysis, but they do not create an approval formula. NIW still depends on the EB-2 basis, the three Dhanasar prongs, the quality of the evidentiary record, and USCIS’s exercise of discretion.

What should not take the place of the proposed endeavor

Some descriptions may provide context but are not sufficient by themselves:

  • the job title or profession

  • the sector’s general importance

  • a list of duties common to the occupation

  • the full résumé without an explanation of future work

  • the name of a business to be opened or an employer

  • broad objectives without projects, means, or explained impact

  • a statement of national benefit without a link to the specific activity

The point is not to make a proposal artificially complex. It is to make clear what work will be evaluated and allow each conclusion to find support in pertinent evidence.

The definition begins the analysis; it is not advance approval

A well-described endeavor must still be examined under all three prongs. It may have substantial merit and still lack demonstrated national importance. A person may have excellent training but not show a sufficient connection between their record and the project. The first two prongs may be supported while the waiver balance still requires its own analysis.

It is also necessary first to establish eligibility in the EB-2 classification, either as a professional with an advanced degree or equivalent, or as a person of exceptional ability in the sciences, arts, or business. NIW does not replace that step.

For that reason, defining a proposed endeavor has a precise function: it delineates the object of analysis. It does not turn a résumé into eligibility, make a profession a priority, or guarantee a favorable decision.

FAQ

No. A profession identifies a general field. A proposed endeavor describes the specific work, projects, objectives, and impacts a person intends to advance in the United States.

No. The endeavor may be advanced as an employee, researcher, professional, institutional collaborator, self-employed person, or entrepreneur, depending on the case. A business or employment can be a means of execution, not a universal requirement or the proposal’s complete definition.

A résumé can support the analysis of the person’s positioning, but it does not replace identifying future work and its impact. The prongs examine different questions and must be shown with related evidence.

No. *Matter of Dhanasar* recognizes that future success cannot be guaranteed. The person must nevertheless show, by a preponderance of the evidence, that they are well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor.

No. The description delineates the analysis. The petition still depends on the EB-2 basis, the three prongs, the full evidentiary record, and USCIS’s discretionary decision.
In this article
ShareWhatsAppLinkedIn

EB-2 NIW

Para compreender como sua trajetória se relaciona com uma atuação profissional específica e com os critérios do NIW, conheça a atuação da Linhares Law em EB-2 NIW.

Conheça a área de EB-2 NIW →
About the author
André Linhares
Founding Partner

U.S. immigration attorney with 15+ years representing international professionals, executives and investors.

Continue reading

Adjustment of Status or Consular Processing in EB-2 NIW: What Changes?
EB-2 NIW

Adjustment of Status or Consular Processing in EB-2 NIW: What Changes?

Adjustment of status and consular processing are different paths to seek permanent residence after the petition—or, for adjustment when permitted, while the I-140 is pending. The comparison requires separating the I-140 from the residence stage and evaluating presence, immigration history, visa availability, admissibility, travel, work, and family.

by André Linhares· 8 min read
RFE in EB-2 NIW: What Does a Request for Evidence Mean?
EB-2 NIW

RFE in EB-2 NIW: What Does a Request for Evidence Mean?

A Request for Evidence (RFE) means USCIS needs proof or clarification on identified issues before completing its review. The notice is not an approval, denial, or prediction of the outcome. Learn what must be read in the document, how the deadline works, and why a generic response may leave the central issue unresolved.

by André Linhares· 6 min read
I-140 Approved: What Steps May Still Remain Until Permanent Residence?
EB-2 NIW

I-140 Approved: What Steps May Still Remain Until Permanent Residence?

Approval of an I-140 recognizes the immigrant petition, but it does not by itself grant permanent residence. Visa availability, adjustment of status or consular processing, and a separate decision on residence may still stand between that milestone and the green card.

by André Linhares· 6 min read